Why the World Government of One Piece is just the worst
Anyone who has read or watched One Piece long enough can agree on one thing: the World Government is the worst. Over the course of the series, they went from simply being the people chasing after Luffy because he’s a pirate to being worse than any outlaw could ever hope to be. If I were to rank dictatorial regimes in fiction, I would put the World Government right next to the Galactic Empire in terms of how vile they are. There’s a reason why people have been using the Straw Hats flag at protests around the world, and that’s because the fans know that it is a symbol of defiance against injustice. They know this because they’ve come to know the ones who rule the world of One Piece are more evil than any outlaw could ever hope to be.
I’m RJ Writing Ink, and I wanted to talk about what is it that makes the World Government such an effective villainous organization in One Piece. Because if there is one thing that Eichiro Oda is excellent at doing, it’s making some of the most vile and disgusting villains you may ever find in a world of manga.
The World Government: EVIL
In the world of One Piece, the shadow of the World Government has been present long before it is formally introduced into the story. They are the ones in charge of the Marines, the forces tasked with maintaining law and order across the world by protecting it from criminals and outlaws. Like any large organization, they have a series of uniform rules and ideals that members are expected to follow. And just like any other large organization, there are going to be people who don’t always conform and subscribe to different beliefs as well as those who only care about their own personal gain. That much is made clear early on in the series thanks to Luffy’s encounters with Marines like Axe-Hand Morgan and Nezumi. The former was a man who effectively bullied those under his command and charge, while the latter was openly taking bribes from pirates like Arlong. However, they’re both counterbalanced by the introduction of Smoker and Tashigi, two Marines who actually do the job they’re supposed to be doing. However, that does not mean that they cannot think for themselves.
When the Straw Hats run into Smoker and Tashigi again during the Alabasta Arc, they wind up dragging them into their fight against Crocodile and his criminal organization. In doing so, they expose this supposed ally of the Marines for his crimes, leading to his arrest. Seeing as how they helped save an entire country, they ultimately decide to let the Straw Hats go when they had the chance to arrest them, with Smoker giving them credit for stopping Crocodile in his report. However, he is disgusted when the higher-ups choose to give him all the credit and cover-up the Straw Hats involvement. On the surface, it’s understandable. They’re trying to save face because they don’t want to admit that a pirate did their job. As we come to learn later, though, this was our first hint that something was wrong with the people running the world.
The Enies Lobby Arc was a Turning Point
I’ve seen several video essays already covering the subject, but the way that Oda reveals just how dystopic the world of One Piece can be is brilliant. In most instances of a dystopian setting, the story makes it clear from the get go just how unfair and cruel something really is. The Empire from Star Wars doesn’t even hide how evil it is. In contrast, though, Oda chose not to let people know straight away just how corrupt the World Government is. Instead, he did it gradually, dropping hint after hint as Luffy and his crew journeyed across the Grand Line that they the World Government was not what it seemed. Until, finally, he proceeds to blow the whole lid on everything several arcs later during the events at Water 7 and Enies Lobby.
For those who haven’t read the manga or seen the anime, here’s a basic summary of the Water 7 and Enies Lobby arcs. While the Straw Hats are dealing with tension between themselves, one of their members, Nico Robin, opts to turn herself into Cipher Pol 9, the World Government’s black ops team. In truth, Robin is actually the sole survivor of Ohara, a nation of scholars that sought to uncover the mysteries of the Void Century, a hundred-year gap in historical records during which the World Government rose to power, and something that they made a crime to research. In response, they burned the entire nation to the ground, killing everyone but Robin, and then lied to the world by claiming Ohara wanted to uncover ancient superweapons.
This moment was a major turning point for the story of One Piece. It made it clear as day to the Straw Hats and to readers that the World Government was, in fact, a tyrannical dictatorship that would stop at nothing to maintain its power, even if it meant killing the people it was supposed to protect. And in response to this, and rightfully so, the Straw Hats declare war on the World Government to get Robin back, utterly embarrassing them in the process. But this was only the beginning of readers learning about the crimes the World Government has committed.
The Celestial Jerkwads
From Enies Lobby onwards, Oda continues to escalate the level of atrocities committed by the World Government. At Sabaody, we are introduced to the Celestial Dragons, descendants of the founders of the organization who live atop the Red Line and see themselves as gods. They can kill, enslave, and torment who or whatever they want, and they can do it because they’re considered gods by everyone. In reality, though, they’re just delusional jerks who represent everything wrong with humanity wrapped into grotesque caricatures. The only reason no one defies them is because the Marines will step in to protect them, even if they’re doing things that are supposed to be illegal.
The Celestial Dragons are really the ultimate symbol of how the World Government is built on lies. They tell everyone that they’re an alliance of equals that works to maintain peace and justice, but to them, it means doing what they want without consequence. That is how they’ve likely always been, and that is why they are so determined to keep the truth of their origins a secret for 800 years, no matter how many people they have to slaughter in the process. To be fair, eight centuries seems unbelievable for a group so corrupt to be in power, but it shows just how effective their methods of maintaining power have been. If anyone tries to step out of line or learn the truth, they will brand them an outlaw and hunt them to the ends of the earth, something that most people cannot afford to be put through.
Now, to be fair, not everyone in the Marines and the World Government are as corrupt as the people in charge. In fact, people like Smoker and Tashigi are some of the most morally upstanding people in the entire series, and there are plenty of others like them. Yet despite these people having a greater sense of justice and could, in theory, change things for the better, they are ultimately forced to stop short of doing so. This is the ultimate trap of the World Government. They make it so that the most moral and just people, AKA the people most likely to effect change, are forced to become cogs in their massive machine. While they can do plenty of good in the Marines, they are ultimately unable to change the status quo without risking being branded outlaws themselves. It’s how the Celestial Dragons have been able to stay in power, and it’s one of the reasons why few have discovered the ultimate lie at the heart of the World Government: Imu.
Imu is the Heart of Darkness
The World Government claims that it is an alliance of equal nations where none are meant to stand above the other. As we know, that is a lie, as the Celestial Dragons and their leaders, the Five Elders, do just that. Yet only a handful of people realize that even this is a lie. In truth, the Five Elders serve their own master, a figure that, for the majority of the series, no one even knew existed: the true ruler of the world, Imu.
To date, we know almost next to nothing about who, or what, Imu even is, as not even the higher-ups in the World Government are aware of their existence. It’s not even clear if Imu is even human, with some believing that they are some sort of demonic entity or dark god. What is known is that they are the embodiment of order and oppression itself, ruling the world from the shadows with an iron fist, and they are determined to keep it that way. Any outsiders who learn of their existence will be hunted down and killed to keep this knowledge from becoming public. Yet that has not stopped some people from finding out anyway and living to tell about it. Were that to happen, then all of their plans would come undone.
For the longest time, fans have thought that the ultimate goal of the World Government was to maintain its power no matter what. And I do mean no matter what. Murder, torture, genocide, racism, brainwashing, whatever heinous act you can think of, the World Government is willing to do it. But I don’t think that even the most die-hard fans could imagine what their endgame might be. If you’re an anime-only watcher or not caught up yet, then turn back now, because there’s going to be a major revelation from this moment on:
The world of One Piece is slowly sinking into the ocean. And the World Government is likely counting on it to happen.
Armageddon is on the World’s Doorstep
During the Egghead Island Arc, it’s revealed that a thousand years ago, the world was once covered by massive continents and a civilization more advanced than anything in the present day. Yet the events of the Void Century would not only see to that civilization’s destruction at the hands of the future World Government, but most of the world being swallowed by the sea. All of the islands that we’ve seen throughout the series were just the tallest points on these continents that survived the flooding. Even that might not be enough anymore as the sea levels continue to rise.
While the person who shared all this information said that it’s unclear who’s responsible for the current state of the world, most fans have guessed that the predecessors to the World Government were responsible. Or, at the very least, took advantage of things to seize control. They’ve kept people isolated on their islands and unable to travel the dangerous seas without them, all while using the Marines to control the seas. They did all of this to keep people in the dark about how their homes would eventually be lost to the sea, leaving the Celestial Dragons atop the Red Line in control of the only remaining dry land. In other words, they’ve spent the last eight hundred years herding the world like cattle to the slaughter.
Ultimately, the world of One Piece may seem like a fun and colorful world of adventure; and for the most part, it is. But underneath that fun and whimsy, Oda has created a world ruled by darkness. And it is this darkness that Luffy is supposed to be fighting against. Why? It’s not just because he wants to be King of the Pirates. It’s because he might actually be the savior of the world. It’s messiah. Pirate Jesus!
