So…how do ya’ll wanna do this?
Growing up as an anime fan came with a lot of joy, and pain. Whether it was reaching breakneck speeds to get to your TV after school to watch the latest DBZ episode, or crashing out because Francis decided to tear up your rare Pokemon and Yugioh cards in front of you; while all the girls laughed in the process. There’s one thing that made it all worth while. A place you can go to talk about all the greatest moments from your favorite anime. A place where debates didn’t turn into full-on warzones filled with toxicity, doxxing, and death threats. A place that…ok, let’s not beat around it. The Anime Community.
Being a part of this community really gave you a sense of belonging, especially if you were considered an outcast by the rest of society. Its a place where anime fans can talk about their favorite shows without judgment or prejudice (you’ll see what I mean about the second one). Now in the year of 2025; you’ve got ‘fans’ sending death threats to anime creators, because they didn’t make their headcannon ‘official’. (Lookin’ at chu MHA!) You’ve got Twitter X activists cosplaying as anime fans trying to inject political agendas into well-established fandoms; followed by the incels online who go to war with said activists. If you’re a Black or Brown (BIPOC) cosplayer, you’ve got ‘fans’ telling you your skin is too dark to cosplay anime characters with a much lighter complexion, or skin tone. Yeah, racism is here too, who’d thought…
So, I want to look at some aspects of the anime community that have changed in the last couple of decades. Let’s start with the obvious one; anime becoming mainstream.
[ANIME BECOMING MAINSTREAM]
This goes back to growing up during your childhood, and watching some your favorite shows. Back in the 90s you had Pokemon, Sailor Moon, and of course Dragon Ball Z. There were many other shows that were around during this era, but back then these were ones that made it out the trenches. It was also during the time where anime clubs started to form in school, of course I never joined any of them because I didn’t know about them at the time. With the Shonen genre of anime on the rise from the late 90s to the 2000s, it led to the trifecta of shows that many still call the greatest era of anime history; The Big 3! (Naruto, Bleach, and One Piece.)
These shows had a stronghold on the anime community, as they were the only shows that were being talked about at the time. Yes, you still had Gundam fans. Yes, Pokemon was still kickin’. Yes, Dragon Ball and Sailor Moon was still holding it down, however those shows walked so the others could ‘Naruto Run’. The anime community had grown from just a few nerds talking around the school lunch table, to large-scale clubs that eventually became the anime conventions that we see today. However its not all sunshine and Skittles, as the reason anime became mainstream…is the same reason most OG anime fans don’t watch (or enjoy) modern anime. To them, classic anime did it better; from storylines, plots, and character development. They’ll make acceptations, but most of the time, they don’t want to be caught in the ‘Peak vs. Mid’ debate. Which leads into the second aspect…
[ANIME DEBATES]
What can I say about them that hasn’t already been said, eh? Anime debates have changed drastically over the last 20 years. I remember growing up we used to have debates about which Pokemon could beat which Digimon in a fight, then laughed about it afterwards. Nowadays if you say Goku could solo the Marvel or DC Universe, best believe you’re getting flamed in the comment section! If you say you don’t like a certain character or the main character and give a reason why, you’re getting flamed in the comment section (especially from AOT fans). I blame social media and the division that its caused among the anime community, because it was never this deep when I was growing up. And DON’T GET ME STARTED ON THE SUB VS DUB DEBATE! I’ve already explained it before, so I’m not doing it again. We have both versions available…and yet we still complain. Legally vs Piracy is another one, as many fans are frustrated with how Crunchyroll is doing business. (Which is ironic because they used to be on the other side.)
From Waifu Wars to Anime’s “Me Too” Arc, these debates have split the anime community down the middle. The drama from these debates have destoryed friendships, relationships, and tainted the integrity of the anime community as a whole. (As well as well-known fandoms.) This is also why a lot of fans have completely left the anime community and don’t tell anyone else that they watch anime, because they don’t want to be associated with that drama. I myself was also on the way out, but I had my own reasons for coming back…
[NEW GEN & 2020 ANIME FANS]
With anime being mainstream, it also brought something that made the modern anime community what it is today; New Gen fans. From 2020-2022 (aka The Covid Anime Fan Era) there was a massive spike in anime viewership from streaming companies like Netflix and Hulu, as well as Crunchyroll. Both 2020 anime fans and new gen fans flooded the anime community, as the medium itself now became socially accepted in society. At the same time, this influx of fans also brought a lot of drama. Keep in mind a lot of these people didn’t start watching anime until Covid hit, plus these are the same people that didn’t watch anime…until it got popular.
I also hear the word “gatekeep” being thrown around whenever this topic is discussed among OG and hardcore anime fans, because of how many times mainstream fandoms have gone down the trash because ‘normies’ and ‘cringey fans’ invaded said fandoms. ‘Twitter X Activists’ have also invaded these fandoms as well and, well…ya’ll know how that story goes.
[APPRECIATION VS APPROPRIATION]
If you were born in the 80s and 90s, then you know anime used to be called ‘Japanimation’, because it came from Japan. It was originally marketed towards adolescent Japanese audiences; until it found its way to the West, got dubbed, and Western adolescent audiences started watching it. As it rose to fame in the 90s and 2000s…wait, I already said that! Y’know what? Screw it, I’m gonna get right to it!
Anime fans both appreciate and appropriate cultural aspects of Japan. Some want to visit Japan so they could see and appreciate the history of the land; from historical places, events, food, and nightlife. While select others follow the Weeaboo path and think Japan IS anime! This can also be said about fanart and cosplay—especially if you’re a minority! I’ve seen some of the most racist comments under Black and Brown female cosplayers, whenever they cosplay characters of a lighter complexion. (Even though most of the characters are Japanese, and not Caucasian.) Some are well aware of the Twitter X controversy that happened, when a black female artist drew fanart of the main characters from Dandadan (Ken Takakura and Momo Ayase), and made them Black. While some people said that there was no harm done (and that art is subjective), that didn’t stop racist fans from coming for this girl’s throat in the comments. It got so bad that the Voice Actor for one of the main characters in Dandadan (A.J. Beckles as Ken Takakura), came to the artist’s defense of her fanart, and they came gunnin’ for him too.
That just shows you where we are with the anime community, and why some people actually hate it. I guess that why so many fans wish that the anime community could go back to the way it used to be. Back then we were chopping it up about our favorite shows and having silly versus debates at the school lunch table. Now the community is crawling wit racists, elitists, weeaboos, lolis, twitter activists, cringey fans, and mainstream normies. I guess that’s why I say…the anime community just doesn’t hit the same.
So…what do you do?
One, start your own anime community. Two, ignore and block people on social media who don’t know you or care about you. Three, watch what you love on your own merits and don’t engage with the online (or offline) fandom if you don’t want (or have) to. Four, stop caring about what other people think if you’re a Black or Brown cosplayer, and cosplay what you love! Five, establish ground rules when you have anime debates, especially the ‘spicy ones’. Six, leave miserable people where they are and don’t engage, because misery loves company. Seven, don’t feel pressured to watch mainstream anime just because someone else said you should. (Follow number three for extra assurance.) Eight, appreciate Japan and its culture and don’t go there just because you think it’s ALL anime. Nine, make sure you keep one foot in reality and go outside, and breathe clean air—if there’s any. Finally number ten, don’t make anime your entire personality. There’s more to life then toxic debates, cringe fanbases, and weeb wars.
I don’t know how I’ll feel about the anime community in the next five or ten years, but the sooner we acknowledge that its got modern problems, then we’re sure to come up with modern solutions.
OG Founder!
Out!
